Recipe of the Day

Barney`s Supermarket

The Ultimate Spicy Cool Combo Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Tip Of The Day

Oui by Yoplait French style yogurt is inspired by our traditional French recipe. It starts with simple, non-GMO ingredients, poured and set in individual glass pots for eight hours. This creates a satisfying thick, subtly sweet, fresh tasting yogurt. And that creates a moment of pure enjoyment in every spoonful. Check out our story at

View Full Shopping List
Recipe Of The Day
Print |  Email To Friend |  Add to Recipe Box

The Ultimate Spicy Cool Combo Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Prep Time: 15 minutes

Cook Time: 8 minutes

Servings: 1 sandwich

The classic grilled cheese sandwich re-imagined with two types of cheese and gypsy peppers.


  3 oz Great Midwest® Jalapeño Jack cheese, shredded

  3 oz Great Midwest® Chipotle Cheddar cheese, shredded

  2 Tbs cream cheese

  1 Tbs sour cream

  3-4 gypsy peppers, finely diced

  Salt & pepper, to taste

  Sriracha sauce, to taste (optional)

  2 Tbs European salted butter, divided

  2 slices mild sourdough bread

Select All

Add Items to List


In a medium bowl, combine the shredded Jalapeño Jack cheese and Chipotle Cheddar cheese. Add the cream cheese, sour cream, gypsy peppers, salt, pepper and sriracha sauce (optional). Mix thoroughly.

Turn pan to medium-high heat; butter pan. Spread cheese mixture on bread and place on grill, covering with second piece of bread. Place a weighted pan or tin-foil wrapped brick on top of sandwich to add pressure and facilitate thorough grilling. After 3-4 minutes, remove sandwich and add remaining butter to pan. Flip sandwich over into pan and re-apply brick. Remove from heat and serve.

*For added flavor, add 1 ounce of shredded Jalapeño Jack cheese to the butter in the pan to build a crispy cheese crust on the sandwich.